@Cyberium Probably, but I was only pushing out a quick reply based on decks I had made or seen. Sorry.

So sad, I prefer the replacement effect because: A) it was a good way to teach players about how replacement effects work B) I prefer legends like Child of Alara to be a choice - abuse as part of the 99 or need hoops to abuse from the command zone, Not a huge deal, but I just put this into the same ...

Thank you everybody. Day 33 Now voting to cut: Land Changes : I have nominated 29 Lands to use in voting for cuts. We now only need 2 votes for each cut. 16 Lands need to be cut. Each day, participants may vote for up to 4 lands to cut. 3 Creature(s) 5 from among Enchantments, Artifacts, and Planesw...

Well, it would depend on what kind of R deck you are interested in. Some initial thoughts (pending input to narrow down options) based on decks I have seen or made: Artifact: Feldon of the Third Path Daretti, Scrap Savant Spells based: Etali, Primal Storm Wort, the Raidmother Aggro: Alesha, Who Smil...

Outcryqq wrote: ↑

4 years ago

I'll nominate to cut Maze of Ith

You may not have noticed, but with so many lands to cut, I made the following change (under "changes" at the top of the summary):

16 Lands need to be cut.
Each day, participants may vote for up to 4 lands to cut.

Day 32 Now voting to cut: Land Changes : I have nominated 29 Lands to use in voting for cuts. We now only need 2 votes for each cut. 16 Lands need to be cut. Each day, participants may vote for up to 4 lands to cut. 3 Creature(s) 5 from among Enchantments, Artifacts, and Planeswalkers 1 from among ...

Back more on topic. Rin and Seri, Inseperable . I've got my changeling deck and I'm very excited to find out they've become this. https://thoughtcatalog.files.wordpress.com/2014/05/screen-shot-2014-05-22-at-4-21-20-pm.png?w=640 I must be old, I don't get that picture but Rin and Seri, Inseperable m...

I generally like these. They are great for 2 and 3 color Landfall decks and can be better than many 3cmc rocks in 2 color decks. They can also be considered when you are already running Amulet of Vigor and other untapping shenanigans. I also like the way the name scheme was devised (which means we a...

Outcryqq wrote: ↑

4 years ago

That means we just have one enchantment/artifact/walker to cut. Can we cast another vote for something we've already voted for? There's a few I wouldn't mind see go.

Sure. I think the dearth of voters kinda makes that necessary.

Day 31 Now voting to cut: Non-Land (2 Remain) Change : Since this has stagnated, I have nominated non-lands to use in voting for cuts. We now only need 2 votes for cuts. 3 Creature(s) 5 1 from among Enchantments, Artifacts, and Planeswalkers 1 from among Instants and Sorceries We should now be at: ...

So Karrthus isn't cut yet? Hm. I thought I'd tried to vote on it previously, but I'm a little confused on the voting now. In any case... I vote for Karrthus. Voting was modified to meet the level of participation. Basically, I nominated enough non-land cards (nomination counts for 1 vote) to have a...

Day 29 Now voting to cut: Non-Land Change : Since this has stagnated, I have nominated non-lands to use in voting for cuts. We now only need 2 votes for cuts. 3 Creature(s) 5 1 from among Enchantments, Artifacts, and Planeswalkers 1 from among Instants and Sorceries We should now be at: 30 Creature...

Day 28 Now voting to cut: Non-Land Change : Since this has stagnated, I have nominated non-lands to use in voting for cuts. We now only need 2 votes for cuts. 3 Creature(s) 5 from among Enchantments, Artifacts, and Planeswalkers 1 from among Instants and Sorceries We should now be at: 30 Creatures,...

There's one vote for Karrthus already, but I can't seem to find where that vote was. It was part of the mass nominations I made to speed the process back on Day 23 or so. maybe we can list cuts. If a category gets overcut, last cuts on that category can come back or we can open a atunement stage No...

Day 26 Now voting to cut: Non-Lands Change : Since this has stagnated, I have nominated non-lands to use in voting for cuts. We now only need 2 votes for cuts (nomination has always counted as the first vote). 3 Creature(s) 5 from among Enchantments, Artifacts, and Planeswalkers 1 from among Instan...

Cutting cards is always harder (read: less fun) than adding them. Anyway, I'll add the third vote for cutting Mu Yanling. True, but it's also that traffic through the experiment dried up - from a high of 14 votes a day, to the recent three votes in 4 days. Day 25 Now voting to cut: Artifacts, Encha...

Updated below

Day 24 Now nominating to cut: Artifacts, Enchantments, Planeswalkers, Instants and/or Sorceries Now voting to cut: Artifacts, Enchantments and/or Planeswalkers Sections will be: 3 Creature(s) 5 3 from among Enchantments, Artifacts, and Planeswalkers 1 from among Instants and Sorceries We should now...

I am saying that mono-color/mono-brown decks are under-powered and overly-restrictive compared to other decks in the format. This causes a bunch of fun commanders to not be used due being not two+ colors. This sounds to me like a possible Meta problem. If the General is compelling enough to a playe...

Yeah, my dislike of the "partner with" so far is mostly due to how invested I am in building Tribal. There just aren't any pairs I care to run. For example, I don't run Pir in an Illusion deck (so it is mono-U Toothy). I can at least hope that we get some future "Partner" cards t...

I don't know that it needs to be that complex. I would just like a set of Mono-colored C16 style partners. Though I would also like to see one or more generals with an ability such as: "This deck may contain cards as long as the color identity includes <C>" or "This deck may use <C> h...

And we moving into instants and sorceries.yet? I'm eyeing Painful Truths . Nominating Spells, Nominating and Voting for NLNC permanents. [HR] Day 23 Now nominating to cut: Artifacts, Enchantments, Planeswalkers, Instants and/or Sorceries Now voting to cut: Artifacts, Enchantments and/or Planeswalke...

Day 22 Now nominating to cut: Artifacts, Enchantments, Planeswalkers, Instants and/or Sorceries Now voting to cut: Artifacts, Enchantments and/or Planeswalkers [*]When we get to cuts, people will nominate a card to cut, and if it receives 5 3 votes within 24 hours , it's gone (until we are at 99 - ...

Day 20 & 21 Now nominating to cut: Artifacts, Enchantments, Planeswalkers, Instants and/or Sorceries Now voting to cut: Artifacts, Enchantments and/or Planeswalkers [*]When we get to cuts, people will nominate a card to cut, and if it receives 5 3 votes within 24 hours , it's gone (until we are...

Subscription to the Twitch channel, but I guess that's also only monthly, like the Patreon. If you'd like to simply donate directly, you can use PayPal to museoffirellc@gmail.com. I suppose we could also set up a VenMo account or something as well. Sent via Paypal, with note. Have you considered ad...